Your search for "recurring nightmare 72" revealed the following:
Recurring Nightmare (EXO) from Exodus, available at 401 Games Canada. Rarity: Rare Finish: Normal Artist: Jeff Laubenstein Card Text:Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to owner’s hand: Put target creature card from your graveyard into play. Play this ability as...
Recurring Nightmare - GLD4-EN041 - Common - Limited Edition from Gold Series 4: Pyramids Edition, available at 401 Games Canada. Rarity: Common Card Text:Select 2 DARK monsters with 0 DEF in your Graveyard and return them to your hand.
Recurring Nightmare - SR06-EN023 - Common - 1st Edition from Structure Deck: Lair of Darkness 1st Edition, available at 401 Games Canada. Rarity: Common Card Text:Target 2 DARK monsters with 0 DEF in your GY; add those targets to your...
Recurring Nightmare - FOTB-EN066 - Secret Rare - Unlimited from Force of the Breaker Unlimited, available at 401 Games Canada. Rarity: Secret Rare Card Text:Select 2 DARK monsters with 0 DEF in your Graveyard and return them to your hand....
Recurring Nightmare - FOTB-EN066 - Secret Rare - 1st Edition from Force of the Breaker 1st Edition, available at 401 Games Canada. Rarity: Secret Rare Card Text:Select 2 DARK monsters with 0 DEF in your Graveyard and return them to...
Recurring Nightmare (WC98) (Brian Selden) from World Championship Decks 1998, available at 401 Games Canada. Rarity: Rare Finish: Normal Artist: Jeff Laubenstein Card Text:Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to owner's hand: Put target creature card from your graveyard into...
Recurring Nightmare - OP06-EN019 - Common - Unlimited from OTS Tournament Pack 6, available at 401 Games Canada. Rarity: Common Card Text:Target 2 DARK monsters with 0 DEF in your GY; add those targets to your hand.